State Farm® Insurance Agent Justin Shelby
Leave Us a Review
Our customers are the center of our universe and we’re grateful for them. If you’re willing to share your experience about your interaction with our agency, it’ll be a great help for other people looking to make smart and confident decisions about their insurance and financial services.
Take 60 seconds (or more if you want) to share your story by clicking on one of the review links below.
What our customers say about us...
Netanya Sweat
January 15, 2026
"I had requested a quote for home and auto insurance and received a call from Erica the very next day. She was super friendly and very patient with me while I searched for all necessary info she needed. They beat my current rates drastically. I recommend anyone looking for insurance to get a hold of Erica for any insurance needs!"
"Welcome to the State Farm family, Netanya! We appreciate you reaching out and working with Erica! "
Home sweet home
January 15, 2026
"Great job getting a coverage in a timely matter during my relocation,and at a good rate! For my Ford!!!!"
"Welcome to the agency David! We appreciate you trusting us with your insurance needs! Let me know if I can help in anyway! "
Stephanie Beahler
January 15, 2026
"Ericka went above and beyond to make sure my kids have life insurance. Due to the amount of accidents in the area the employees stayed late to ensure their customers were insured. I'm glad to have an insurance company that cares that much for their customers. I definitely recommend Justin Shelby State farm to people I know. :)"
"Thanks Stephanie! We appreciate you trusting us with your life insurance needs! It’s so important to protect your family with life insurance!! "
Lisa Harper
January 14, 2026
"Lacey from the west plains office has been such a great help to me with any insurance need I’ve had. She always goes above and beyond to help with the utmost of professionalism and efficiency. I’ve been with State Farm for over 30 years and they have consistently given me better coverage and rates all these years."
"Lisa, we appreciate the kind words! We really appreciate your loyalty and business over the last 30 years! "
Brandy PureRomance
January 12, 2026
"Telisha is phenomenal had my insurance quoted and ready to go right away"
"Thanks Brandy!! We appreciate you trusting us with your insurance needs!"
Daniel Newcomb
January 9, 2026
"Justin Shelby State Farm is top notch. His entire staff is great, especially Lacey and Karen. I've always had great interactions with them."
"Daniel, please let us know how we can earn that extra star! Your feedback is very important to us. - Justin"
Michelle Mattsfield
January 8, 2026
"Lacey is always amazing to work with when you have a question or taking care of your account. She goes above and beyond."
"Thanks Michelle! We appreciate your business and trust!"
Dillon Harper
January 7, 2026
"Lacey helped me and is the best! Thanks a bunch"
"Thanks Dillon! We think Lacey is pretty great too! "
Hollie Smith
January 5, 2026
"We’ve been with Justin Shelby for 8+ years and have had all great experiences! Today I spoke with Telisha and she was very helpful with great customer service. 🤩"
"Thanks Hollie! We appreciate you and your loyalty!"
Diana Wells
December 19, 2025
"Erica Lee always goes above and beyond to help me and family. She has amazing communication skills explains everything to me thoroughly. I appreciate her so much. She always gets me the most coverage for the lowest price."
"Thanks Diana! We appreciate you trusting us with your insurance needs!"
Louis Colaiannia
December 17, 2025
"Lacey is the best! She is very knowledgeable and friendly. Just the best!!"
"Thanks for the great 5 Star review, Louis! Lacey does an amazing job helping our customers! "
Tracy Deal
December 5, 2025
"Lacey was very friendly and helpful."
"Thanks for the 5 Star review! We appreciate you and glad Lacey was able to take care of your needs! "
Emily Scarbrough
November 26, 2025
"Erica was the BEST! She made everything so quick and easy. It was a very pleasant experience!"
"Thanks Emily! I’m glad Erica was able to take care of your insurance needs quickly! "
Maryann Pennington
November 23, 2025
"Erica was so helpful with our insurance needs. She went above and beyond for us. She answered so many questions and helped me to see we were very under insured on our house and helped us to save a bunch on our auto premiums. She was great!"
"Thanks Maryann! I’m so glad Erica was able to help you with all your insurance needs! We appreciate you!"
Kyle Tillman
November 22, 2025
"Excellent to work with! Explained things well and helped us get the most coverage at the lowest price!"
"Thanks Kyle! We appreciate you! "
susie miller
November 19, 2025
"Erica and Lacey are wonderful always a great help!"
"We appreciate you Susie! Thanks for the kind words and 5 Star review! "
David Rosas
November 19, 2025
"Lacey is the best! She has done a great job on getting me the cheapest rate on car insurance than anyone else in town."
"Thanks David! We think Lacey is pretty great too 👏. We appreciate you trusting us with your insurance needs!"
Mavis Heavener
November 13, 2025
"Lacey done a great job. She is very nice and got us cheaper insurance than anyone else around. We look forward to continuing to work with her."
"Thanks Mavis! Lacey does a great job for us. We appreciate you trusting us with your insurance needs! "
Nicholas Crocitto
November 5, 2025
"I want to start off by saying that i was skeptic on which insurance company i wanted to reside with. Lacey was the representative who reached out to me to provide me with my auto insurance and when I tell you she is the most personable rep i have ever had the pleasure of speaking with, that would be an understatement… She is by far the realest person I have had the pleasure of speaking with! She was super quick with providing me the details, she had me laughing and cracking jokes all while doing a straight forward quote. I was reluctant enough to have her as my representative as she 1000% is an outstanding voice and face for this insurance firm! I couldnt be happier with my quote, with my coverage and most importantly my choice for my insurance coverage. I will continue to refer and recommend specifically to Ms. Lacey Brotherton as she is a sweetheart and treats and speaks to you like an actual person rather than a statistic or number, as any person should. It shows that she is passionate about her career, and she does not lack empathy or compassion! Thank you so much again Lacey! I so look forward to continuing my coverage with you for a long time to come! Thank you for being YOU in short!"
"Wow, thank you for the kinds words about Lacey! She truly is one of the best! We appreciate you and look forward to working with you! "
Mikayla Wright
October 29, 2025
"Great place to do insurance with! I’ve been with them since I started driving and they’ve done me so well."
"Thanks Mikayla! We appreciate you trusting us for all your insurance needs! "
Jason Sage
October 27, 2025
"The account rep, Lacey, I spoke with today overly exceeded my expectations and was very quick about account changes to my policy,and I do recommend this company at the upmost highest recommendation for all of anyone's auto/home/life/& any other insurance needs. With great respect Mr. J. Sage"
"Thanks for the kind words and 5 Star review! We appreciate you trusting us with all your insurance needs! "
Jessica Colvin
October 22, 2025
"Trying to manage insurance and buying property from 1300 miles away has many obstacles, Erica made it easy, seamless and reassuring. The customer service was exceptional but the way she was personally invested in taking the time to invest into our needs is what made us choose State Farm. After much research and cost comparisons for the product we felt because of her effort, honestly and transparency they would be the most trusted for our family. Thank you Erica"
"I’m glad Erica and the team were able to help and provide the value you were looking for. We appreciate you trusting us with your insurance needs! "
Mary Reed
October 17, 2025
"Agent Erica was awesome... She had a great sense of humour all while helping me out by setting up my acct AND saved me $30/month.... I loved working with her... She wasn't a "stuffed shirt" kind of agent... I would recommend anyone I know wanting to check out new or transfer policies to ERICA at Justin Shelby State Farm ... Thank you, Erica, for your sincere and helpful with a good policy ."
"Thanks for the kind words and ( Star review, Mary! Erica and the rest of the team do our best to make everyone comfortable and make the insurance process as smooth as possible. We appreciate you! "
Robert Jones
October 15, 2025
"The agent Erika was very helpful and was able to find me the best fit for the Jeep I was adding to my other policies."
"I’m glad Erica was able to help you get the best policy for your Jeep! We appreciate you!"
don kentner
October 15, 2025
"Erica strived to offer me good rates and was very pleasant to work with! I will be adding more policies as they come do and have started my referrals in her direction as well."
"Thanks Don! I’m glad Erica was able to help with your insurance needs! We appreciate you and the referrals!"